Issue Number:FDR-211
Phase: Design
Decommissioning Process Fuel Debris Retrieval
Investigation Subject Structural integrity
Issue Ensuring structural integrity of PCV and building
Needs
① Inspecting and monitoring structures for integrity
Time Axis: Fuel Debris Retrieval [Mid-Term]
Desired state and reasons for it
In order to maintain the support functions of important equipment and facilities such as the PCV and the RPV for safe fuel debris sampling and retrieval, it is desirable to inspect and monitor the integrity of the structures that have functions to be maintained (including the support function and the confinement function).
For the inspection and monitoring, it is desirable to develop accessibility, installation, and evaluation methods for inspection equipment. In addition, alternative inspection or monitoring methods and maintenance technologies are desirable for cases where access is not possible due to a high radiation environment.
Current state against ideal
Due to the earthquake that occurred off the coast of Fukushima Prefecture on February 13, 2021, a drop in the PCV water level was confirmed in Unit 1 and 3. It is assumed that this drop in water level may have been caused by an increase in the amount of leakage from inside the PCV due to changes in the status of the PCV damaged areas that have been confirmed so far and the occurrence of new damaged areas. The necessary technology development is required to strengthen the monitoring system to grasp changes in plant conditions, to evaluate the impact of such changes on the maintenance and management of facilities and buildings with a medium- to long-term perspective, and to understand the status of the plant.
Since the suppression chamber (hereafter S/C) legs are submerged by stagnant water, it is assumed that corrosion thinning will progress. Therefore, in order to suppress corrosion thinning in Government-led R&D Program on Decommissioning, Contaminated and Treated Water Management, an electrolytic corrosion prevention method considering the actual equipment environment is being investigated.
A survey conducted in 2023 in the PCV of Unit 1 revealed the loss of concrete in the pedestal section. Based on this result, it was determined that the following should be done: (1) evaluating the impact of dust dispersion at the site boundary, including the case when the RPV sinks to cause an opening equivalent to a main steam pipe in the PCV, based on the assumption that the support function of the pedestal cannot be expected, (2) implementing possible countermeasures regardless of the evaluation results, and (3) conducting evaluation regarding the structural impact on the RPV and PCV in the event that the support function is lost and the RPV sinks.
Regarding the evaluation of the loss of support function, it is evaluated that this function will not lead to large-scale damage as a result of the strength evaluation assuming earthquake motion.
Issues to be resolved
It is required that the monitoring system is strengthened to understand changes in plant conditions, impact assessments are made to manage the maintenance of equipment and buildings with a medium- to long-term perspective, and the necessary technology is developed to understand the status of the plant.
As concrete is constantly changing in response to the environment, it is necessary to constantly evaluate concrete deformations by image analysis, install accelerometers to monitor responses to small earthquakes and peculiar deformation behaviors, and evaluate building rigidity based on the vibration properties. In addition, in order to understand the allowable amount of deformation, it is desirable to continuously monitor not only cracks and corrosions but also deformations and fractures.
For structures that cannot be accessed due to the high-dose environment, or for structures that cannot be inspected sufficiently for structural integrity even with remote technology, it is necessary to develop methods to estimate the condition and environment of the structure (including statistical analysis methods and various testing methods).
② Evaluating structures for long-term integrity
Time Axis: Fuel Debris Retrieval [Mid-Term]
Desired state and reasons for it
In order to take measures to maintain the functions (including the support function and the confinement function) to be maintained by important equipment and facilities such as the PCV and the RPV, it is desirable to understand the effects of the accident, the earthquake resistance of structures based on aging and deterioration, and the effects of damage suffered in the accident. In such a case, it is desirable to evaluate the integrity of the structures by analyzing the accident progress, using the status and condition of the structures obtained from actual plant investigations.
In order to maintain the integrity of structures and piping, which forms a boundary having a function of confining radioactive materials during the debris retrieval, it is desirable to understand the degradation phenomena such as corrosions of the structure in an environment where air including oxygen flows inside the PCV by negative pressure control and corrosion progresses every moment in the process of decommissioning. It is desirable to take coordinated actions regarding corrosion degradation, because containment methods vary widely when a change occur in the oxygen concentration in the PCV.
It is desirable to be able to confirm the presence or absence of degradation (for example, corrosion and cracks) specific to the 1F environment in a flow in the gas and liquid phases.
In order to evaluate the long-term integrity of structures, it is desirable to produce outputs with high accuracy by combining the inspection and evaluation methods.
Current state against ideal
The PCV, which forms a confinement boundary for use in the atmosphere, is made of carbon steel with low corrosion resistance. After the accident, the 1F is forming a special environment containing suspended matter and deposit with high radiation under high room temperature and knowledge about corrosion phenomena in this environment is insufficient. Water is supplied into the PCV to cool fuel debris, and carbon steel is immersed in water. It is also known that oxidizing chemical species such as hydrogen peroxide and various radical species are generated by radiolysis of water.
If the PCV is maintained under negative pressure during fuel debris retrieval, the oxygen concentration will increase due to an air inflow, and there is a concern over a progress of corrosion in structural materials of the RPV and the PCV and necessary piping. Based on the past investigations, however, it is expected that the seismic safety margin against standard earthquake motions can be secured even if reduced steel thickness due to corrosion for 40 years is taken into account.
For further corrosion inhibition measures, on the other hand, Government-led R&D Program on Decommissioning and Contaminated Water Management is investigating the applicability of corrosion inhibition measures to prevent corrosion of structural materials of the RPV and the PCV and necessary piping over the long-term decommissioning period and maintain the current status in actual equipment.
For the PCV, the RPV, and the piping, the effectiveness of corrosion inhibitors for steel materials has been tested in consideration of the effects of radiation environment and seawater input. Candidates for effective corrosion inhibitors have been identified for general or localized corrosion.
In order to control corrosion thinning of the S/C pedestal, which is submerged by stagnant water, an electrolytic corrosion prevention method considering the actual equipment environment is being investigated in Government-led R&D Program on Decommissioning and Contaminated Water Management.
The survey in the PCV of Unit 1 conducted in 2022 and 2023 confirmed that a part of the concrete in the pedestal was missing.
Issues to be resolved
In order to mitigate the effect of corrosion inhibitors on the existing circulating water cooling and purification system, it is necessary to reduce the concentration of corrosion inhibitors at the preliminary stage of purification. In future investigations on the PCV circulating cooling system, it is necessary to comprehensively examine the measures for corrosion inhibition and the measures for satisfying other required functions.
In particular, the possibility of corrosion of the S/C legs will be an issue. It is essential to develop a monitoring method for the position. Since inspection is difficult, combination with evaluation technology is required.
Further investigation is needed on the long-term deterioration of concrete. Parts that can be inspected are not considered to be a problem, but for example, the pedestal foundation of the RPV is difficult to monitor, so a combination with an evaluation technique is essential.
③ Establishing a measure for maintaining structural integrity
Time Axis: Fuel Debris Retrieval [Mid-Term]
Desired state and reasons for it
It is desirable to have a technology for maintaining structural integrity in case aging, coolant leakage, or failure of dynamic equipment is discovered as a result of integrity evaluation by inspection and evaluation technologies, or in case it is necessary to add a new structure to the existing one.
Current state against ideal
Regarding integrity assessment using inspection and evaluation technologies, the investigation on evaluation methods for seismic resistance was conducted in the past.
Issues to be resolved
It is necessary to establish methods for evaluating integrity through inspection and evaluation technologies, and to investigate the technology for maintaining integrity assuming about factors that may affect integrity.
Relevant Issues
References
- FDR-211 (PDF)
- Overall Diagram (HTML, PDF)
- Overall Diagram (Detailed Version) (PDF)
- Download all diagrams (diagram_en.zip, 9.4 MB)
- List of issues
Please note that this English text is a provisional translation of the Japanese original.